We are going to take a look at the comparison between Cat Genie vs Litter Robot, two self-cleaning litter boxes that are among the most popular models in the market right now.However, they use entirely different technologies, so they provide different benefits and have different weaknesses. Continue reading below to find out which one is better for your cat!
Read on to learn about:
– The dimensions and set-up requirements of each model
– The features and technologies of each model
– Which model that is quieter and has better odor control
– Which one that has better overall performance
– The warranty and maintenance cost of Cat Genie vs Litter Robot
– Which self-cleaning litter box that is generally more recommended
First of all, let’s take a look at the set-up requirements of these two self-cleaning litter boxes. Cat Genie has smaller dimensions, so it is more portable and space-friendly. However, the installation is a little bit more complicated. On the other hand, Litter Robot is quite large, but the installation is relatively easier. See also: Furminator vs Groom Ninja.
Cat Genie measures 19.2 inches wide, 21 inches deep, and 24.5 inches tall. It is indeed not very big, so it doesn’t require too much room. However, it should be placed near a toilet, as it needs a water line for cleansing and a toilet where it can dump the waste. It also needs an electrical plug.
Such requirements may make Cat Genie difficult to install. Placing it near a bathroom may be inconvenient, especially if you often get guests in your home. Some odor from the unit may spread into the bathroom.
On the other hand, Litter Robot is quite bigger and bulkier. It measures 24.25 inches wide, 27 inches deep, and 29.5 inches tall. The large size may make it tricky to place, especially in a small home. However, things become a lot easier because all it needs for the installation is a power outlet. It can be placed wherever you want as long as it has an access to a power outlet.
Litter Robot is convenient because you can just put the unit behind your home, or in a room that is far from your guest room. This way, you don’t need to worry about the bad odor when receiving a guest.
Cat Genie is a fully automated system. It works with washable, biodegradable granules for the litter. It is especially suitable for allergy sufferers because it doesn’t cause any dust. However, it your cat has wet poops, the results may turn out to be less than good.
While rotating the litter around, Cat Genie will put out an automated hand to scoop any solid feces inside. The collected feces is then liquefied by a saline solution and dumped into the toilet for sewage treatment. Cat Genie also has a good urine removal mechanism, as any liquid in the machine will drain right to a reservoir to be mixed with the odor-killing saline solution.
With Cat Genie, you don’t need to change the granules frequently. It uses clean water and a cat-safe sanitizing solution to scrub and clean the granules. Afterwards, it aerates the granules to dry them.
On the other hand, Litter Robot is not fully automatic. You need to open the base drawer to remove the waste at least once a week. Nevertheless, it can work with any type of litter, so finding new granules for the unit should be easy.
In order to remove the feces, Litter Robot will flip upside-down so that the litter goes through a screen to be collected in the base drawer. Meanwhile, any urine will be clumped by the granules and then disposed in the same way as the feces removal. Litter Robot can handle wet poops pretty well without a mess.
Litter Robot also has a night light. This is nice if your cat is unable to see clearly in the dark. There is an indicator to tell you if the drawer is full and needs to be emptied.
In general, both Cat Genie vs Litter Robot have good odor control. However, there are some potential quirks. While the saline solution used by Cat Genie is really effective in eliminating odor, Cat Genie will still emit a strong odor if the cat defecates soft feces. This is because the soft feces is not handled properly and then get stuck inside.
Litter Robot traps the waste in the base drawer. It is equipped with a carbon filter to prevent excessive odor from escaping. However, the base drawer is not completely airtight, so there is still some odor that may escape.
The nice thing about Cat Genie is that it is very quiet in the first 26 minutes of the 30-minute washing cycle. It is as silent as a purr, so it will not disturb anybody’s sleep when working in the night. However, in the last 4 minutes, it becomes notably louder.
Some people hate the fact that Cat Genie works very slowly. It takes about 30 minutes to clean the litter properly. But since it is fully automated, you probably don’t need to put much thought on it.
Litter Robot is pretty loud. It is slightly louder than an average refrigerator. Fortunately, it comes with a Night Mode. The unit will not rotate for 8 hours after you activate the Night Mode, or until you turn the mode off. This is very convenient if you don’t want your sleep to be disturbed by the noise.
However, Litter Robot is really fast. It only takes roughly 2.5 minutes to complete a cleaning cycle. This is understandable because the unit actually only moves the feces to the base drawer.
Maintenance and Warranty
When choosing between Cat Genie vs Litter Robot, don’t forget to consider their maintenance costs. The difference can be quite significant. Cat Genie has two things that need to be constantly replaced, the cleaning solution cartridge and the granules. Hence, the maintenance can be more expensive.
A 120-wash cartridge usually costs about twenty four dollars or so. If the unit washes twice a day, a cartridge can last for two months. Meanwhile, the granules still need to be replaced once per month because the granules are bio-degradable. Cat Genie has a 2-year warranty.
On the other hand, Litter Robot only needs the granules to be replaced once per month. It doesn’t use washable granules. Using regular granules can save you some money. The warranty goes for 18 months.
Cat Genie Vs Litter Robot
In general, Litter Robot is more recommended. The primary reason is that it is more reliable. It can handle both solid feces and wet poops with good results. In addition, it is easier to install. It only needs a power outlet. It also works more quickly and it has lower maintenance cost.